Short answer
A waitlist tells you your message made people curious and that some of them were willing to give their email or phone number. It does not tell you they will pay. To get from interest to evidence, talk to the people who signed up and put a small pre-sale in front of them. That is the answer you can make a decision on.
What a waitlist is
A waitlist is a simple page that says what you are building and asks people to sign up so they hear when it is ready. It is cheap to make and a good place to start, because it shows you whether your message reaches anyone.
But signing up costs people very little. Someone was curious for a moment and gave their email. That is a long way from someone who is ready to pay.
What it can tell you
If the people you send to the page do not sign up, your message is probably not clear, or you sent it to the wrong people. That is a useful answer in itself. Banoo's lens asks two questions here: who is your customer, and what is your message in one sentence.
If they do sign up, you learn something else as well: which message and which channel worked best. If you show two versions of the message to two groups, you can see which one draws more people in.
What it cannot tell you
A waitlist does not tell you how many people will really buy, at what price, or whether they will stay after they buy. Many people sign up and then forget. So do not mistake the size of the list for the size of the market or the number of customers.
If you filled the list with friends and acquaintances, even the interest may not be real. Take only sign-ups from strangers seriously.
Turn interest into commitment
The next step is to contact the people who signed up. Ask them why they signed up and how they solve that problem today. Then put a real offer with a price in front of them: a pre-sale, a small deposit, or a first place for the first version.
The number of people who go from the list to a pre-sale tells you far more than the list itself. If nobody on the list was willing to pay, the list was a weak signal, however big it was.
- Make a page with a clear message and a sign-up form.
- Send people from your target group to the page, not your friends.
- See which message and which channel brought the most sign-ups.
- Talk to a few of the people who signed up.
- Offer them a pre-sale at a real price.
Common mistakes
Collecting a list for months without talking to anyone. Giving a prize for signing up, which brings people who only want the prize. And starting to build just because the list got big.
A waitlist is a first step, not final evidence. Use it to find the right people, then run the real test with those same people.
Common questions
How big should a waitlist be?
The number does not matter. What matters is how many people on the list committed when you put a real offer in front of them. A small list with a few pre-sales is worth more than a big list with no purchases.
How long should I keep the list open?
As long as it teaches you something new. Once you know which message works, it is time to move to a pre-sale, not just to make the list bigger.
What do I say to the people who signed up?
Say plainly what you are building and ask them why they signed up. People answer more easily when they can see you really want to hear it.
Terms in this guide
Last reviewed:
This guide is a method, not a promise of results. Your situation is not the same as anyone else's.
Ask the board your own question