Short answer
An idea has been tested when a few strangers were willing to pay for it or make a real commitment, not when your friends said it was good. So before you build, write down your assumptions, talk to people who have the problem, and put a very small version or a pre-sale in front of them. Their answer tells you more than any plan.
Why test first and build second
Most ideas do not fail because of how well they were built. They fail because nobody wanted that thing at that price. If you find that out after building, your time and money are gone. If you find it out before, you spent a few weeks and a few conversations.
Testing means looking for an answer you might not like. If you are after approval from the start, you read every answer in your own favour. Captain asks one simple question here: what has to be true for this idea to work?
Write down your assumptions
Every idea stands on a few assumptions. For example, that a specific group has this problem, that the way they solve it now is poor, that they would pay for a better way, and that you can find them. Write these down one by one.
Then next to each assumption write what would prove it or disprove it. An assumption you have no evidence for is still an assumption, however sure you are. The board puts the same "Assumption" label on numbers with no source.
Talk to people who have the problem
Before anything else, talk to the people you think are your customers. Ask them about the last time they ran into this problem, what they did and how much they spent on it. Do not talk about your idea. Ask about their life.
If someone cannot remember one specific time this problem bothered them, the problem is probably not that serious for them. How to run these conversations is in the customer interview guide.
Put something small in front of them
Talking is not enough, because people are polite and say "Yes, I would definitely buy it". Real evidence is when they do something small that costs them: a deposit, a signature, time for a second meeting, or an introduction to someone else.
The product does not need to exist. A simple page with a description and a price, a manual version you run yourself behind the scenes, or a written offer is enough. What matters is that a real person faces a real decision.
- List the assumptions behind your idea.
- Next to each assumption, write what would prove it.
- Talk to a few people who have the problem about their past.
- Put a small offer with a price in front of them.
- See who gave money or a real commitment, not who said it was good.
How to read the answers
If a few strangers paid, you have a real signal and can take a bigger step. If everyone said it was good but nobody committed, something is off: either you picked the wrong customer, or the problem is not important enough, or your offer is not clear.
A no is not a failure. It is the cheapest place you could have found out. Go back with those same notes and change one of the assumptions, not all of them at once.
Common questions
What if someone steals my idea?
The hard part is usually the doing, not the idea. The more real danger is building something nobody wants. Talking to customers lowers that danger.
How many people is enough?
There is no magic number. When the answers start to sound alike and you hear nothing new, it is time for the next step. More important than the count is that those people really are your target customer.
Does encouragement from friends and family count?
No. They love you and do not want to upset you. Hear what they think, but get your evidence from strangers who have no reason to be polite.
Terms in this guide
Last reviewed:
This guide is a method, not a promise of results. Your situation is not the same as anyone else's.
Ask the board your own question