When to drop an idea

Lens: Mo's experience, as chair of the boardLast reviewed:

Short answer

Drop an idea when, after a real test, the condition you wrote down at the start for carrying on has not been met, and changing one part of it has not helped either. The best time to write that condition is before you start, while you are not yet in love with the idea. Without it, your feelings make the decision, not the evidence.

Set the condition in advance

Before you put in a lot of time and money, write down what has to happen by a set date for you to carry on. For example, that a few strangers pre-buy, or that one channel brings customers, or that your spending stays under a limit. Write the condition somewhere you cannot change it later.

When the date comes, ask only one question: was the condition met or not? This takes a hard decision out of the middle of excitement and tiredness.

Signs that are serious

Some signs weigh more than others. After several real attempts, no stranger has been willing to pay. Customers buy but do not come back. Each customer costs more than their profit and you see no way to change that. Or your money or your energy is running out faster than the evidence is coming in.

One sign is inside you: if you no longer care about the problem and only carry on because you feel you owe it to people, that is an answer too.

Signs that mislead

Praise from friends and family, likes and sign-ups that never turned into purchases, and the feeling that "it is nearly there". These may cheer you up, but they are not evidence for carrying on. The opposite holds too: one bad week or one angry customer is not, on its own, a reason to drop the idea.

Pivot or let go

It is not always one or the other. Sometimes only one part of the idea is wrong: you picked the wrong customer, the channel is wrong, or the offer is not clear. Changing one part and keeping the rest is called a pivot.

The simple rule is to change only one part at a time and test it again with a condition and a date. If you have changed different parts several times and the condition is still not met, the problem itself or the market itself is probably wrong. Then dropping the idea is the most sensible decision.

  1. Before you start, write down the condition for carrying on and its date.
  2. Until that date, run real tests, not just busy work.
  3. On the date, ask only: was the condition met or not.
  4. If not, change only one part and set a new condition.
  5. If you have changed it several times and it still has not worked, let it go with a clear mind.

Once you have let it go

The idea is gone, but what you learned stays: the people you talked to, the channels you tried, and the skill of selling. Write down what you learned and what you will test sooner next time.

Tell the people who bought from you or were waiting for you plainly what happened, and if you hold any of their money, give it back. That keeps your reputation for the next idea. Dropping an idea at the right time is a skill, not a failure.

Common questions

How do I know I did not give up too early?

If you measured the condition you wrote in advance against a real test, and changed one part several times, it is not too early. If you did none of that and are simply tired, it may be too early.

What if I have spent a lot of money?

Money already spent does not come back, whether you carry on or not. The right question is whether, from today on, carrying on is worth new time and new money.

Can the board make this decision for me?

The board can put the evidence side by side and say plainly what it sees, but the decision and the responsibility for it are yours. Mo gives the verdict; you do the work.

Terms in this guide

Last reviewed:

This guide is a method, not a promise of results. Your situation is not the same as anyone else's.

Ask the board your own question